
Ian Hartitz ranks fantasy-relevant WRs for the 2023 season, breaking them into tiers and providing ADP and key info about what to expect from each player.

Yes, the NFL season doesn’t start for basically another six months.
Also yes, fantasy football never sleeps and it’s always a great day to be great.
What follows is the first edition of my 2023 fantasy football WR tiers. The players are indeed ranked in order inside of the specific tiers; just realize the disparity is far wider between tiers as opposed to individual rankings.

Check out Fantasy Life’s ADP tool for updated average draft positions throughout the offseason.
Pretty, pretty, pretty special. Arguably the best in NFL history:
The NFL’s reigning king in receptions (128) and receiving yards (1,809), Jefferson has the requisite combination of high-end volume and elite talent to stand tall as the overall fantasy WR1 entering 2023.
Seriously: How is any mere mortal supposed to guard this guy?
Absolutely. While things were virtually dead even from a pure target perspective through 20 full games together, Chase really took the lead in a major way in 2022.
Overall, Chase has posted a 174-2623-21 receiving line on 258 targets in 30 full games alongside Higgins (151-2179-14 on 227 targets) since entering the league in 2021. Hell, Chase nearly had as many targets in 15 total games last season (162) as he did in 21 contests back in 2021 (163).
Chase has an elite workload and ranks fifth in PPR points per game since entering the league behind only Cooper Kupp, Davante Adams, Justin Jefferson, and Tyreek Hill.
I’ll happily roll with the Bengals’ 23-year-old stud as my overall WR2 thanks to his objectively superior QB situation compared to each of those aforementioned fellow top dogs.
The legit track star set career-high marks in targets (170), receptions (119), and receiving yards (1,710) alike in his first season with the Dolphins; the only “problem” was a relatively middling seven receiving scores.
Hill’s game-by-game route trees look like a maze from one of those old National Geographic magazines you’d scan at the doctor’s office; it’s not like head coach Mike McDaniel isn’t doing enough to maximize the talent here.
Still, Tua Tagovailoa just led the NFL with a 6.3% pass TD rate; plenty of research suggests this rate will dip in a potentially meaningful way in 2023.
Overall, 83 QBs have posted a TD rate of at least six percent with a minimum of eight starts since 2000. Among those who again started eight games the following season: A whopping 62 of 68 signal-callers (91%) saw their rate decline during their encore campaign.
The median (-1.7%) and mean (-1.65%) demonstrate that not every high-efficiency QB completely falls off a cliff the following year, but it’s still tough to be overly optimistic about Tua finding even more success filling up the stat sheet in 2023.
Don’t get it twisted: Hill deserves to be in any conversation surrounding fantasy and real life’s single-best WR, but I’ll take my chances on the former LSU teammates at the top of drafts thanks to their slightly higher scoring ceilings.
It’d make sense if they are because…just how much better can the man be? Overall, Diggs has peeled off 127-1535-8, 103-1225-10, and 108-1429-11 receiving lines since teaming up with Josh Allen in 2020. Only Davante Adams, Cooper Kupp, Tyreek Hill, and Justin Jefferson have averaged more PPR points per game during this span.
Of course, Father Time is undefeated, and Diggs turns 30 in November. This is historically when WRs go from great to good in fantasy land: Only 14 WRs have posted top-12 seasons in PPR points per game after turning 30 over the past 10 years.
Nothing about Diggs’s 2022 performance indicated a major drop-off in performance was imminent, and the Bills (to this point) haven’t added any target competition to worry about. Age alone isn’t enough reason to completely fade somebody; just realize it’s enough to serve as a tiebreaker when compared against similarly elite talents with absurdly fantasy-friendly volume.
We might not have to find out. Stafford said he wasn’t going to retire earlier this offseason, but there have been some murmurs indicating that’s not entirely out of the question. I do anticipate Stafford playing in 2023; just realize this is one of the key injury situations to monitor throughout the offseason.
All Kupp has done with Stafford is work as fantasy’s overall WR1 in PPR points per game in back-to-back seasons. However, Kupp’s lone contest with John Wolford under center didn’t instill a ton of confidence: The Super Bowl MVP caught three of five targets for negative one yard in 40 snaps before suffering a season-ending ankle injury.
It’d be reasonable to rank Kupp as THE overall WR1 with full assurance of Stafford being under center for 17 games in 2023, but that’s hardly the case at the moment, so instead he’s jerking the curtain on the position’s top-five talents. Still not too shabby!
While Jimmy Garoppolo might not have the same level of arm strength and/or escapability as Aaron Rodgers or even Derek Carr, Garoppolo has been astoundingly good over his career from a yards per attempt perspective: No QB since the 1970 merger has averaged more yards per attempt than Jimmy G (8.3) with a minimum of 50 starts.
Garoppolo has also done a good job enabling fantasy-friendly teammates over the years, leading each of George Kittle (85-1053-5 in 2019), Deebo Samuel (77-1405-6 in 2021), and Brandon Aiyuk (78-1015-8) north of the thousand-yard mark during his three seasons with 10-plus starts.
Only Justin Jefferson (184) demanded more targets than Adams (180) last season; head coach Josh McDaniels knows exactly who his offense’s No. 1 pass-game weapon is.
Perhaps Jimmy G spreads things out a bit more than Adams’s fantasy managers would prefer, but there’s still more than enough high-end talent and volume upside here to fire up the 30-year-old veteran as a top-six option in 2023.
This leaves us some incremental value in best ball drafts on Underdog Fantasy, where you can get a 100% deposit match of up to $100. Take advantage by following the offer below and start drafting today.
Definitely in terms of counting numbers, and pretty much even when focusing on pure efficiency:
Brown didn’t demand quite as many targets on a per-route basis (that Devonta Smith guy is pretty special too), but the more pass-happy nature of the offense relative to the Derrick Henry-led Titans made up for it with a bigger overall target pie.
AJB is finally receiving the sort of workload that his high-end talents deserve. Fire up the reigning WR7 in PPR points per game as just that; if anything, expectations deserve to be higher considering the Eagles’ depleted defense could force their offense to keep its collective foot on the gas during far more fourth quarters than last season.
The Cowboys were already a run-heavy team with now-Chargers OC Kellen Moore at the helm in 2022, so new play-caller/incumbent head coach Mike McCarthy’s desire to “run the damn ball” might not be quite as detrimental as Twitter is making it out to be.
The larger issue might be the team’s potential to regress in the scoring department due to the change. There’s not much room to go except down anyways:
And yet, Lamb’s breakout 2022 campaign happened even with Dak Prescott missing five games. The 24-year-old WR was deployed all over the formation and regularly found ways to individually make big-time plays through both YAC goodness and exceptional hands.
The addition of Brandin Cooks could help spring Lamb back to 2021-level efficiency, although a more crowded offense could do the same to his volume. Ultimately, this latter factor is the only thing keeping Lamb out of the position’s top-five conversation; he’s still a no-doubt upside WR1 as a perennial top-tier scoring offense’s clear-cut alpha pass-game option.
It’s hard to see why not. The 2021 fourth-round pick has earned at least nine targets in an incredible 18 of his last 20 games.
While “upside” is generally associated with players capable of scoring an 80-yard touchdown in the blink of an eye, target-vacuums like St. Brown kill their fantasy competition with one thousand paper-cuts in the form of supreme full-PPR friendly workloads.
All tongue-in-cheek Twitter jokes aside: The insertion of Jameson Williams really does profile as a potential positive for St. Brown considering the sort of gravity the 2022 first-round pick figures to command from safeties.
The Sun God was one of just nine WRs to average at least 2.4 yards per route last season; he remains the preferred underneath and intermediate maestro inside of the league’s reigning fifth-ranked scoring offense.
Only two men averaged more yards per route run than Waddle (2.59) last season: Tyreek Hill (3.2) and Justin Jefferson (2.62). Nobody with an average target depth of at least 5.5 yards was more lethal than Waddle in terms of yards after the catch (6.9). Only Stefon Diggs (124.3) and Christian Watson (123.3) garnered a higher passer rating when targeted than Waddle (122.6) among 80 WRs with at least 50 targets.
Yeah, the Dolphins’ rising third-year WR was pretty special in 2022.
The potential “problem” is Waddle had a workload closer to a WR3. In fact, his 12.9 expected PPR points per game ranked just 27th at the position. He joined A.J. Brown and Tyler Lockett as the only WRs with more than 40 fantasy points above expectation, which is cool in the sense that this means these guys are really f*cking good, but also not that cool in the sense that they don’t have much margin for error due to their relatively limited volume.
Waddle rather inexplicably averaged just 5.6 targets per game during the final seven weeks of the season. The talent here might be outrageous, but at least in 2022, the Dolphins were more than willing to feature Hill as the true No. 1 option.
Waddle isn’t the only WR with this problem—only so many players are force-fed 150-plus targets per season—but it’s still enough of a problem to keep him closer to the WR1 borderline despite last year’s overall PPR WR8 finish.
Expecting another special year from Waddle? You can bet on him on BetMGM and get up to $1,000 paid back in bonus bets when you create a new account and follow their First Bet Offer below.
Not very, but it happens. Overall, there have been 18 instances of teammate WRs posting top-12 numbers in PPR points per game in the same season since 2012—good for an average of 1.6 occurrences per season.
Ja’Marr Chase and Higgins accomplished this very feat in 2021. While things didn’t work out quite so well in 2022, Higgins had three separate games produce lowly snap rates of 1%, 16%, and 26% due to injury. Excluding those, he averaged a robust 16.6 PPR points per game, which would have been good for WR11 status in 2022.
The rising fourth-year talent might be an overqualified No. 2 WR, but there’s plenty of production available inside the Bengals’ high-flying passing attack. I’d rather go with this archetype vs. a worse WR inside of an offense with a slightly higher volume ceiling.
Not much! A.J. Brown had 167 targets in 20 combined regular season and playoff games, while Smith came in at 158. Brown did have fantasy-friendly leads in targets inside the 20-yard line (16 vs. 12) and average target depth (13 vs. 10.2), but clearly this is far more of a 1.A/1.B situation than a major drop-off from No. 1 to No. 2.

Nov 20, 2022; Indianapolis, Indiana, USA; Philadelphia Eagles wide receiver DeVonta Smith (6) runs with the ball while Indianapolis Colts cornerback Isaiah Rodgers (34) defends in the first quarter at Lucas Oil Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Trevor Ruszkowski-USA TODAY Sports
“Skinny Batman” had at least eight targets in 11 of his last 12 games in 2022; there’s more than enough volume to go around inside of the league’s reigning third-ranked scoring offense.
While Smith might struggle to get the sort of monstrous 150-plus regular season target workload that is usually required for a top-five finish, the former Heisman Trophy winner is more than talented enough to (again) turn in borderline WR1 production with slightly less than ideal volume.
Maybe. The man is a baller after all.
Wilson deserves a medal for putting up an 83-1103-4 receiving line while catching passes from Zach Wilson, Mike White, and Joe Flacco; just look at how Elijah Moore responded to dealing with that group.
While the Ohio State product did benefit from Corey Davis missing four games, Wilson’s average of 9.9 targets per game after the team’s Week 10 bye reflects the reality that he was the engine of this offense down the stretch.
The rising second-year stud is certainly priced a bit closer to his ceiling than floor, although there’s serious boom potential as the rather undisputed No. 1 WR in an offense presumably led by Rodgers.
I’m drinking the Kool-Aid to an extent; just be careful about going too far out of your way in ranking Wilson over similarly-talented WRs in far more established passing games.
Metcalf (141 targets) led the way over Lockett (117) last season, but the former did play one more game than the latter. Credit to Lockett for winning out in PPR points per game (15.1, WR14) compared to Metcalf (13.6, WR23).
It’s unclear what the eight-year veteran has to do at this point to earn some respect in fantasy land. Lockett has smashed his ADP on an annual basis ever since landing a full-time starting job in 2018:
Turning 31 in September isn’t ideal, although the iron man has missed just three (!) total games since entering the league in 2015. Lockett (rather hilariously) seldom exposes himself to big hits.
The volume and age advantages are enough to give Metcalf the nod, but their average draft position is (again) far too wide. Drafters should feel free to prioritize lower-ranked WRs over Lockett due to the ADP gap; just realize Geno Smith’s top-two receivers will be neck-and-neck in the rankings come Week 1.
We haven’t seen Ridley play football in a while.
Friendly reminder: He’s really good.
Reinstated after missing all of 2022 due to suspension, Ridley appears to be healthy and ready to go if his AWESOME piece in The Players Tribune is any indication.
Ridley has worked as the WR14 in PPR points per game among all receivers to play at least 16 games since 2018, after all. His ceiling as Trevor Lawrence’s likely No. 1 WR is awfully high; I’m all in on staying ahead of ADP to get as many shares as possible this offseason.
Pretty, pretty, pretty special. All Olave did in 2022 was average the fifth-most yards per route run by a rookie receiver over the past 10 years:
The 2022 NFL Draft’s No. 11 overall pick benefited from both Michael Thomas and Jarvis Landry missing plenty of time with injuries; just realize a ridiculous volume-hog role isn’t as necessary when a player comes with this sort of absurd per-route efficiency.
Adding Derek Carr to the equation is a net positive considering his ability to enable the likes of Davante Adams, Hunter Renfrow, Michael Crabtree, and Amari Cooper to varying degrees of fantasy success over the years. There is some potential for Thomas to regain his No. 1 role, but ascending 23-year-old talents who were that good as rookies shouldn’t be faded.
Not good, although typically terrible late-season Cleveland weather didn’t help matters. Overall, Cooper only put forward one top-30 PPR performance during Watson’s six starts of the season.
That said: Cooper is still very much one of the game’s premiere route-running technicians and managed to make the absolute most out of the Jacoby Brissett experience.
It’s possible there’s more volume on the table than ever inside of Kevin Stefanski’s typically run-heavy offense. One of Matthew Berry’s 23 most interesting things he heard at the NFL combine stated that the Browns “are really going to open up the offense. Go five wide. Pass a lot. This is going to be Deshaun Watson's offense, not Nick Chubb's. They will pass a lot more than folks expect.”
Watson’s long-time No. 1 WR DeAndre Hopkins saw north of 150 targets in all four of their seasons together. Cooper will be 29 in June, but the potential for an even bigger target workload and a return of pre-2022 Watson is too much to pass up.
Fire up Cooper as the top-20 WR he was in 2022 in both realized and expected PPR points.
Hamstring, ankle, and knee injuries certainly didn’t help, but things weren’t going great even before suffering the former injury at the end of Week 7. Overall, Samuel was just the WR18 in PPR points per game during the first seven weeks of the season; he finished as the WR28 on a per-game basis for the entire season.

Oct 3, 2022; Santa Clara, California, USA; San Francisco 49ers wide receiver Deebo Samuel (19) runs with the ball as Los Angeles Rams linebacker Leonard Floyd (54) pursues during the fourth quarter at Levi's Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Kyle Terada-USA TODAY Sports
The thing is, Deebo was only the WR21 in expected PPR points per game (13.5) in 2022. This wasn’t too far removed from his mark in 2021 (15, 14th); the difference is that Samuel scored an unreal 98.5 PPR points above expectation in 2021 (No. 1) compared to -2.9 in 2022 (129th).
Samuel’s breakout 2021 campaign was thanks to him averaging an absurd 18.2 yards per reception to go along with an unsustainable 59-365-8 rushing line. The rising fifth-year veteran still led the NFL in yards after the catch per reception last season, but a changing offensive dynamic led to his average target depth cratering from 8.6 yards to 4.5.
This offense is absolutely loaded and accordingly doesn’t need to force feed one particular member. Deebo will still make plenty of great plays—he’s a great football player after all—but he’ll need to once again go super saiyan to make up for another potential WR3-level workload. That’s tough to prioritize too far up in the WR2 ranks.
There should still be plenty of betting opportunities for Samuel this season, and you can get up to $1,000 paid back in bonus bets on your first bet if it does not win thanks to BetMGM. Follow the offer below to claim yours.
Wildly in favor of Allen during the 33 games in which each all three have been healthy enough to play at least 30% of the game’s snaps. Their per-game production in these contests is as follows:
The case for Williams is that things have gotten a bit closer over the last two years in terms of both per-game opportunity (9.6 targets vs. 7.7) and fantasy production (16.5 PPR points vs. 14.8). Allen turns 31 in April; there have only been 14 instances of a 30-plus year old WR turning in top-12 fantasy production over the past decade.
Of course, Allen stands as one of those qualifiers thanks to his sterling per-game production in 2022 when healthy enough to suit up.
The Chargers sure don’t look to be moving on from Allen as one of Herbert’s top-two pass-game weapons. If anything, he could be needed more than ever should Austin Ekeler’s trade demands be met; I’m comfortable being ahead of ADP on the 10-year veteran thanks to the reality that his Week 1 and on rankings will smash the current middling WR3 ADP.
Meanwhile, Williams has earned a bit of a boom-or-bust label over the years. His tendency to crash to the ground like a bag of rocks in contested-catch situations has occasionally led to an early exit, but the six-year veteran has still managed to play in 85 of a potential 92 games since entering the league in 2017.
Investing in either of Herbert’s top-two pass-game options should be good for fantasy business if new OC Kellen Moore can replicate some of his rather awesome (regular season) success.
I discussed this very topic on the March 27th edition of The Fantasy Life Podcast with Dwain “The Rock” McFarland. Obviously the artist known as Nuk would help all 32 teams, but his personal fantasy value would certainly benefit from a situation with minimal target competition and/or high-end overall scoring upside.
Dwain and I arrived at the following tiers of teams:
Immediately locked in as WR1:
Maybe not the No. 1, but offense should be dope so probably fine:
Better real life than fantasy landing spot:
McLaurin’s 2022 production was particularly impressive when you grind the film and realize just how many times he won against some of the league’s top CBs: None of Jaire Alexander (5-73-1), Stephon Gilmore (6-113-0), or Darius Slay (6-102-0, 8-128-0) had much of an answer for the Commanders’ undisputed No. 1 WR.
Unfortunately, style points don’t count for anything extra in fantasy football, and McLaurin has to get used to yet another QB change.
Speaking of McLaurin’s career QBs: Want to see a dead body?
It’s possible Sam Howell (throws a pretty deep ball!) or Jacoby Brissett (legit good in 2022! No. 3 in CPOE!) are better than anything else McLaurin has dealt with. Things certainly can’t get much worse: Taylor Heinicke (48.9 PFF passing grade, 47th) and Carson Wentz (58.9, 39th) were two of PFF’s 10 lowest-graded QBs in passing among 48 qualified signal-callers last season.
McLaurin has provided borderline WR2 production throughout his career despite a never-ending carousel of mediocre QB play. It’s possible, if not likely, this continues, but he’ll be an absolutely screaming value at present mid-tier WR3 valuation if not. I’m willing to find out; McLaurin is priced far closer to his demonstrated high floor than ceiling.
Rather awesome. Like, really good:
Overall, the artist known as Hollywood worked as the PPR WR5 before breaking his foot.
Read that last sentence again. Madness. Only Stefon Diggs, Cooper Kupp, Tyreek Hill, and Justin Jefferson had more PPR fantasy points than Brown during the first six weeks of his Cardinals career. His pre-injury pace: 122-1374-9—and he looked good doing it!
Yes, that stretch occurred with a healthy Kyler Murray under center. It’s likely, if not probable, that Murray will miss a decent bit of 2023. Brown posted mediocre 4-34-0, 4-19-0, 3-57-0, 6-61-0, and 1-7-0 receiving lines after Murray was injured during the final six weeks of the season.
Also, yes, DeAndre Hopkins is tentatively expected to be playing elsewhere this season. The long-time target hog was featured well ahead of Brown during their three weeks together and regularly commanded double-digit targets from Kyler before the injury.
Buried in the WR3 ranks at the moment, Brown profiles as one of fantasy’s potential mid-round gems thanks to his potential to see 150-plus targets in an offense that will hopefully have something close to a high-end QB under center for at least half the season depending on Murray’s eventual status.
It’d obviously be great for Brown’s fantasy value if Murray gets back to full health sooner rather than later; just realize there should be enough volume on the table to more than keep the ship afloat in the meantime.
I’m in on Brown well ahead of ADP. So is he.
I hope so. There probably isn’t a single WR in the NFL that has suffered more from porous QB performance than Moore over the past half-decade.
Maybe Terry McLaurin, but I still lean Moore. It’s a minor miracle that Moore has managed to continue supplying WR3 fantasy goodness along the way:
Give the Bears’ franchise QB credit for making a handful or two of truly awesome throws in 2022, but Justin Fields ranked outside the NFL’s top-20 signal-callers in accuracy rating (25th), deep ball completion rate (22nd), pressured completion rate (24th), and clean pocket completion rate (27th).
The NFL’s reigning second-most run-heavy offense in non-garbage time pass-play rate, only the Titans, Panthers, Ravens, and Falcons offered fewer expected PPR points per game to their WRs than the Bears in 2022.
Yes, Fields is likely an upgrade for Moore over what he dealt with in 2022. Also yes, it’s possible that the improvement in passing efficiency won’t be enough to make up for reduced volume inside of a passing game that could add a day one pick to the equation.
Young QBs like Jalen Hurts, Josh Allen, Kyler Murray, and Joe Burrow took their game to another level when their respective offenses added a true alpha WR1 to the equation; just realize Moore is being drafted far closer to his demonstrated ceiling than what he’s been for the better part of the last three seasons.me
You might have heard Johnson didn’t score a single TD in 2022. His 147 scoreless targets are 38 more than the next-closest tally since the metric began being tracked in 1992.
Transitioning from Ben Roethlisberger to Kenny Pickett certainly didn’t help in year one. Johnson was one of just five receivers who scored more than 30 PPR points below expectation on the season:
Eight drops didn’t help (tied for the second most in the NFL), although it’s not like anyone is complaining about Stefon Diggs (9) leading the way.
Perhaps the larger concern is Johnson’s mediocre 2.8 yards after the catch per reception, a bottom-10 mark that ranks alongside veterans like DeAndre Hopkins and Mike Evans.
Attempting to discern whether Johnson’s 2022 was simply terribly unlucky, or more so the result of him simply not being a great football player, is one of the more important questions of the offseason. He made my “All-Sheesh Team” for all of his near misses; there were more than a few instances of the four-year veteran coming oh so close to coming down with a spectacular catch.

Oct 30, 2022; Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA; Pittsburgh Steelers wide receiver Diontae Johnson (18) is knocked out of bounds by Philadelphia Eagles safety Marcus Epps (22) at Lincoln Financial Field. Mandatory Credit: Eric Hartline-USA TODAY Sports
Ultimately, Johnson joins Tyreek Hill, Justin Jefferson, Stefon Diggs and Davante Adams as the only five receivers with more than 450 targets over the past three seasons. While he wasn’t as successful with Pickett under center, the 2022 campaign did prove that the 26-year-old talent is certainly still this offense’s No. 1 WR.
Johnson posted WR22 and WR8 finishes in PPR points per game during the 2020 and 2021 seasons before last year’s WR41 disappointment. Of course, he’s accordingly now being priced far closer to his floor than ceiling; I’m happy to scoop up all the shares I can get as long as the ADP remains in borderline WR3 territory.
Pretty much! Kirk set career-high marks in receptions (84), receiving yards (1,108), and receiving TDs (8). He also performed well when it mattered, posting 8-78-1 and 7-52-1 receiving lines in two playoff performances.
And guess what: Kirk looked good while doing so. Displaying a mix of pristine route-running ability and after-the-catch goodness, Kirk posted top-30 marks at the position in PFF receiving grade (76.1, 28th) and yards per route run (1.79, tied for 29th).
Unfortunately, Kirk’s reign as the Jaguars’ No. 1 WR might be over in the form of Calvin Ridley. Hell, Kirk (133 targets) wasn’t even featured that far ahead of Zay Jones (121); it’s possible—if not likely—that the ex-Cardinals WR struggles to see the same sort of volume in 2023.
Good news: Most of this concern is already being priced into Kirk’s WR3-level ADP. He’s still a featured member of an ascending passing attack; fire up last season’s WR19 in PPR points per game as a high-floor WR3 inside an offense worth investing in.
Yes. The man’s 2022 route-running mixtape is as good as anyone out there.
Aiyuk’s 78-1,015-8 receiving line was good for career-best marks across the board, although he did benefit from Deebo Samuel missing four games throughout the season.
The 49ers put forward the following target distribution in five games with Brock Purdy and Samuel both fully healthy:
Aiyuk isn’t dealing with just Deebo, as both CMC and Kittle warrant (and at times demand) similarly high target shares on a week-to-week basis. There’s little doubt that Aiyuk has flashed serious high-end ability, but it’s tough to move him too far up the WR3 ranks due to the absolutely loaded nature of this 49ers offense.
The question comes from the reality that the Buccaneers QB change could quickly turn things south for the entire offense. Tampa Bay’s reigning 25th-ranked scoring offense will be led by either Baker Mayfield or Kyle Trask; it’s safe to say things probably aren’t going to get better.
Convenient for this metaphor, new Buccaneers OC Dave Canales served as Geno Smith’s QB coach last season. Yes, Mayfield has spent the better part of the last two seasons being an objectively bad QB. Also yes, he has at least flashed more best-case upside than your typical low-level QB, setting the NFL record for touchdown passes by a rookie (27 before Justin Herbert broke it) and leading the Browns to their first playoff victory since 1994.
Jarvis Landry posted WR25 and WR21 production in PPR points per game in 2018 and 2019 with Mayfield as his starting QB. Even Odell Beckham Jr. posted WR33 and WR38 numbers in 2019 and 2020. Things weren’t as pretty over the last two seasons, but it’s not like Mayfield has *zero* history of putting up at least below-average passing production.
Both Evans (77-1,124-6) and Godwin (104-1,023-3) managed to post top-15 production in PPR points per game despite last season’s turmoil. Fantasy managers certainly weren’t thrilled that Evans took until Week 17 (10-207-3) to really boom, but I’m not a fan of “take away a player’s good games and look they were actually bad” analysis.
Both WRs have posted top-16 PPR production on a per-game basis in four consecutive seasons. Similar to the other WRs in this tier: Their depressed ADP makes sense considering the obvious red flag, but even a below-average passing attack could still produce quality fantasy players with enough volume. Don’t look any further back than literally last season to find such an example for both.
Better than every other rookie WR with at least 50 targets not named Chris Olave. Overall, Watson’s average of 2.26 yards per route run ranked 11th among 80 qualified WRs; just imagine how great things would have been without his infamous drop on the Packers’ first offensive play of the season.
Of course, it took until Week 10 for the rookie to show any real signs of life, but after that he posted four consecutive top-10 PPR finishes. The hot stretch cooled off over the final month of the season; at a minimum, Watson still proved capable of winning weeks thanks to his big-play ability—even occasionally (one time) with Jordan Love under center!
Obviously the potential for Love to be a severe downgrade from Aaron Rodgers is the problem. There’s also the reality that Watson never caught a TD or had more than 50 yards in a game that Romeo Doubs was also active. The Packers (hopefully?) will add at least another body to the room in the draft.
Top-10 in PPR points above expectation, Watson’s big-play ability obviously shouldn’t be held against him, but there’s a low floor here should Love struggle to run the offense. Look at Watson a bit more as a boom-or-bust WR3.
It was! London ripped off 6-95-0, 7-70-0, 7-96-0, 5-47-0, and 6-120-0 receiving lines during the final five weeks of the year, getting a solid eight-plus targets on each occasion.
London was flashing some lethal route-running ability for a man his size even before the late-season breakout. Turning 22 in July, it’d make sense if the 2022 NFL Draft’s No. 8 overall pick’s late-season ascension is the sign of more to come.
The gargantuan-sized problem in the room: TE Kyle Pitts was sidelined during the final six weeks of 2022, undoubtedly helping London obtain a more consistent target share inside the NFL’s single most run-heavy offense.
Overall, London had just one game with eight-plus targets in Weeks 1 to 11 with Pitts active vs. five such performances during the final six weeks after. Their workloads were nearly identical when both were healthy.
Note that Desmond Ridder starting the final four weeks of the season also played into this volume equation, but that’s also another reminder that Ridder and/or Taylor Heinicke probably shouldn’t be expected to supply consistent high-end efficiency inside an offense that didn’t have any last season.
London would be pushing for a top-20 spot on this list with even league-average potential volume and play under center. That leaves some meat on the bone given his current ADP of WR24 on Underdog Fantasy, where you can get a 100% deposit match of up to $100 by following the offer below.
Pittman does deserve credit for his 99-925-4 receiving line; he worked as the WR22 in PPR points per game. Still, his efficiency numbers all declined in a major way after improving across the board from his first to second season:
Obviously, Matt Ryan and Sam Ehlinger didn’t help matters, but it’s also not a given Gardner Minshew or a rookie signal-caller vastly improve the league’s reigning 30th-ranked scoring offense.
New head coach Shane Steichen certainly helped engineer an awfully lethal Eagles offense over the past two seasons; just realize Pittman once again needs to prove himself to an entirely new play-caller and QB—neither of whom are guaranteed to be, what’s the word, good in 2023.

Jan 8, 2023; Indianapolis, Indiana, USA;Indianapolis Colts wide receiver Michael Pittman Jr. (11) catches a touchdown in the first quarter against the Houston Texans at Lucas Oil Stadium. Mandatory Credit: Trevor Ruszkowski-USA TODAY Sports
Pittman’s porous track record of washed QBs is complemented by him never having faced any sort of meaningful target competition—it’s possible the latter variable changes in a meaningful way during the 2023 NFL Draft.
At 27th in PPR points per game over the past two seasons, I’m treating Pittman as the WR3 he’s been as opposed to the upside WR2 he could be in a better overall offense.
Trade rumors have surrounded Jeudy throughout the offseason after he set career-high marks in receptions (67), receiving yards (972), and TDs (6) alike in 2022. The Russell Wilson experience has certainly been an overall failure so far, but Jeudy’s end-of-season boom shouldn’t be ignored:
Of course, head coach Sean Payton’s new offense doesn’t guarantee to feature Jeudy ahead of Courtland Sutton or even Tim Patrick (seriously). It remains to be seen if Wilson will rebound from his career-worst 2022 campaign, or if the reigning 32nd-ranked scoring offense will once again function as one of the league’s least fantasy-friendly environments.
Jeudy tied for 12th in yards per route run (2.18) and ranked 21st in PFF receiving grade (77.9) last season; he has the underlying efficiency numbers of a stud WR…if only the offense can improve.
Those rather awesome efficiency numbers still only produced a WR20 mark in PPR points per game due in large part to a WR36 standing in expected PPR points per game; careful about spending too heavily on the most expensive piece of a still rather unknown (and potentially terrible) passing attack.
Fantasy Life director of analytics Dwain “The Rock” McFarland had the following to say about Williams as a prospect last season:
“The 21-year-old receiver is the best deep threat in the class. He ranked among the top five FBS receivers in touchdowns on deep passes, yards after the catch (YAC) per reception and yards per deep route run. Williams’ speed helped him separate from defenders unlike any other receiver in college football last year.
The difference between Williams finding fantasy success compared to being a bust is if he’s able to deal with the physicality of NFL cornerbacks and run a complete route tree. Some of his top comparisons are to DeSean Jackson and Will Fuller V. Both players were also known for their speed and had some excellent games, but were unpredictable on a week-by-week basis.
Williams is taller than the average speedy receiver which gives him a chance to be a more complete receiver than Jackson or Fuller, but he likely needs to add more muscle. He caught only four contested targets and had only 11 catches when he wasn’t either open or wide open. It’s hard to fault him for being able to get open, but even the best NFL receivers don’t get open as often as he did in college. How he will handle this transition is unknown.”
Williams wound up touching the ball just twice in six games as a rookie. It was cool that those two touches produced a 41-yard TD as well as a 40-yard rush, but it was largely a lost first season. There was also the rather awesome 66-yard TD in Week 18 that was called back by penalty.
Still, just 15 other WRs drafted in the first round failed to gain at least 250 receiving yards as a rookie. The list is not great! Obviously the injury context adds credence to the idea that Williams will be in a far better position to contribute in 2023; just realize it’s rare to see these sorts of major bounce-backs.
And yet, Williams finds himself as the clear-cut No. 1 outside WR inside of the league’s reigning fifth-ranked scoring offense after the Lions didn’t re-sign D.J. Chark. It’s reasonable to expect far more production in 2023—it can’t get much lower—but it’s tough to immediately expect top-30 goodness from a player who has gained more than 160 receiving yards in one season since 2019.
Burks’s rookie season never quite got grooving. Turf toe and a concussion limited the 2022 NFL Draft’s 18th overall pick to just 11 total games, and Ryan Tannehill wasn’t active for the last three of those contests.
The allure of Burks is simple: He flashed down the stretch and remains the clear-cut No. 1 WR inside an offense with arguably less target competition than any other unit in the league. It’s rare to find a first-round WR with sky-high target share potential available this late in drafts.
The problem: The Titans remain fully devoted to the religion of giving Derrick Henry as many touches as possible. Perhaps new OC Tim Kelly changes things, although he was already the team’s passing game coordinator last season.
Burks will be on the rise should the Titans decline to add another serious resource to their WR room during the draft. While that does seem unlikely, the rising second-year talent profiles as someone capable of providing some booms regardless. He’s appropriately priced along the position’s WR3 borderline.
Toney has “it.” I mean, how many other WRs have you seen adjust their gloves during the middle of the play before making a dope contested catch downfield?:
Of course, there are a few more quantifiable reasons to be excited about Toney’s fantasy potential with the Chiefs.
The 24-year-old talent never reached even 50% of the offense’s snaps during his 10 games in Kansas City due to injury (hamstring) and learning the offense, but the former 20th overall pick of the 2021 NFL Draft did flash some of the ridiculous movement skills that made him a fantasy dark horse in the first place.
Whether it was his Super Bowl punt return or breaking tackles against the Jaguars: Toney plays football like he’s moving on fast-forward.
A true featured role would instantly boom Toney into upside WR2 territory, although that’s hardly a guarantee. Travis Kelce will continue to be the offense’s No. 1 pass-game option, while future draft picks could complicate the team’s tentative starting three-WR set of Toney, Skyy Moore, and Marques Valdes-Scantling.
The salivating upside on the table has me in line with Toney’s borderline WR3 ADP, although Moore is probably the better cost-adjusted dart at the moment. At a minimum: Please, injury gods, let the ex-Giants talent at least stay healthy for a full season so we can find out once and for all if the hype is truly warranted.
With so many rookies in this tier, you could find an edge by drafting them before the NFL draft. Sign up for Underdog Fantasy below to get a 100% deposit match of up to $100 and start drafting them today.
Projected targets are a great way to round out your WR corp on Underdog Fantasy, where you can get a 100% deposit match up to $100 by signing up with the offer below.
We saw the one-week upside from these receivers in the past, and they're worth late-round selections in best ball drafts with the ability to pop on any given week. You can draft them with a 100% deposit match of $100 on Underdog Fantasy with the offer below.
Sometimes, all you need is one nice thing to say about a player to make them worth betting on. These players will often have incredibly long anytime touchdown odds, but with BetMGM's First Bet Offer, you can get up to $1,000 paid back in bonus bets if your first bet does not win. Claim yours below.
Looking to dive this deep into the WR position in best ball drafts? You can get a 100% deposit match of up to $100 with Underdog Fantasy by using the offer below.
Betting on these WRs on a week-to-week basis is a daunting proposition, but with BetMGM's First Bet Offer, you'll provide yourself with a level of protection. You can get up to $1,000 paid back in bonus bets if your first bet does not win by following the offer below.