We put too much stock in talent.

You’ve probably heard the cliché that fantasy points are at the intersection of talent and situation. However, our focus is typically on the first part. Go back to the offseason. Check some of those training camp highlights we all used as fuel to boost a player’s ADP. It didn’t matter that those routes were in shorts and against a skeleton-crew defense. We confirmed our priors about our guy. Bring on real football! However, if five weeks have taught us anything, we have to consider more than just how often each receiver gets the ball.

It's part of why evaluating defensive matchups should be a part of our weekly process. Sure, some guys can transcend their environment. And we hope some of them are on our rosters. But even if there’s some concern, I’ve found a few receivers with the skills and surrounding conditions to deliver in Week 6.

Matchups to Target

Courtland Sutton vs. Jets

Courtland Sutton emphasizes my point about considering talent and situation. Because with him, his 16.1 PPR PPG (WR11) underscores his ability once he gets the ball. Of the 32 WRs with a +20.0% target share, Sutton is, at worst, middle of the pack in yards per route run and YAC per reception. However, things are different for the eight-year veteran in Bo Nix’s second season. 

• Target Rate: 23% (2025), 26% (2024)
• Air Yard Share: 38%, 48%
• End-Zone Targets: 33%, 75%

As Nix tries to establish a reliable WR2, Sutton’s weekly target counts have ebbed and flowed. His games with a target rate under 20% come in between the ones above 20%. Week 5 was an ideal matchup, as the Eagles entered the contest allowing the seventh-most yards to perimeter WRs. Facing the Jets has a similar setup.

On average, HC Aaron Glenn’s defense looks average for opposing WRs. They’re 17th in PPR PPG allowed to the position. However, their opponents have included the Steelers, Bills, Buccaneers, Dolphins (when Tyreek Hill was injured) and Cowboys. Which two teams got over 100 yards on the perimeter? Tampa (Mike Evans) and Dallas (George Pickens). Plus, the Jets may be down a slot corner, which forced one of their rotational safeties to play closer to the line of scrimmage in Week 5. If the adjustment allows for more shots downfield, expect Sutton to benefit from the coverage gap.

Premium

Go FantasyLife+

Your league is unique. Your advice should be too. Get personalized tools, rankings, and projections tailored to your fantasy football league settings.

Learn More

Quentin Johnston vs. Dolphins

I’m willing to bet that the Ladd McConkey Bros are praying for my downfall. After seeing their guy finally find the end zone—17.4 PPR points!—I go right back to Quentin Johnston. However, before you get too upset, I’ll direct you to Justin Herbert’s throwing tendencies through Week 5. Let’s see if we can figure out why McConkey reasserted himself as the WR1 in Week 5.

• Week 1: 2.79 (average time to throw), 10.1 (air yards per attempt) 
• Week 2: 2.86, 9.0
• Week 3: 2.79, 9.1
• Week 4: 2.50, 6.5
• Week 5: 2.55, 3.8

As I mentioned in the intro, we overrate talent and gloss over situation. None of this is to say Johnston is better than McConkey. However, when you face a defensive front like the Commanders, which boasts top-10 marks in pressure rate and time to pressure, attacking the short area of the field is a reasonable approach. However, Miami isn’t as effective when it comes to putting opposing QBs into conflict.

• Pressure Rate: 31.3%, 22nd
• Time to Pressure: 2.5 seconds, 24th 

Usually, teams have run on the Dolphins, which partly explains their defense giving up the eighth-fewest PPR PPG to WRs. But the Chargers are down both starting RBs. A lean toward the passing game would make sense here. And with the Dolphins allowing a 62.7% passing success rate to perimeter WRs (versus 41.9% to the slot), Johnston’s talent and situation lend themselves to a solid performance on Sunday.

Sneaky Matchups

Stefon Diggs vs. Saints

Admittedly, there’s nothing “sneaky” about a WR who just earned 12 targets and put up more than 140 yards for the first time in almost five years. I only put Stefon Diggs here because he’s still a part-time player.

• Week 1: 70% (route rate)
• Week 2: 58%
• Week 3: 55%
• Week 4: 82%
• Week 5: 64%

Of course, given how often Drake Maye has looked to Diggs over the last two weeks, we don’t need a full route regimen. More importantly, when he’s been on the field, the former Bills’ WR1 has operated as New England’s best option to keep the offense moving.

• Third/Fourth Down Target Rate: 29.3%, 1st (among all NE pass-catchers)
• Target Share when QB Pressured: 25.7%, T-1st 

So, yes, I’d expect Maye and Diggs to continue building on the rapport we’ve seen over the last couple of weeks. However, the potential for a lopsided game (Patriots favored by 3.5 points on the road) would put a strong outing for the 31-year-old WR at risk. And while the Saints are allowing the seventh-fewest PPR PPG to opposing WRs, the ones that have performed well line up with Diggs’ role and skill set.

• Jaxon Smith-Njigba: 20.6 (PPR points)
• Jauan Jennings: 19.9
• Marvin Harrison Jr.: 18.1
• Khalil Shakir: 17.9

Everyone on the list is their team’s WR1. But more importantly, think about their on-field deployment. Smith-Njigba and Jennings won on multiple in-breaking routes to work after the catch. Marvin Harrison Jr.’s (much-needed) touchdown came on a well-designed out-breaking crossing pattern from the slot. All of which Diggs has shown he can still do, which should keep him in our starting lineups for Week 6.

Josh Downs vs. Cardinals

Note: I’m caveating all of this with the assumption that Michael Pittman’s (albeit minor) hamstring injury was the root cause.

Josh Downs now has back-to-back weeks with a +70% route participation rate and five or more targets. Even better for the Colts’ slot man, Week 5 marked the second time going over a 20% target share. When Daniel Jones hasn’t been pressured and allowed to operate in rhythm (less than 2.5 seconds to throw), Downs has seen a 25% target rate in consecutive weeks. Coupled with the Colts running the most plays in their opponents' red zone, rostering a piece of the passing game has some merit.

The Cardinals are below the league average in receiving yards allowed to slot receivers. Interior options like Hunter Renfrow (9-48-2), Jaxon Smith-Njigba (5-79-0) and Chris Olave (13-54-0) all finished with double-digit PPR points after going up against Arizona’s coverage. Coupled with the projected game environment (46.5 points, tied for seventh most in Week 6), Downs has viability as a bye-week fill-in at the WR spot.

Matchup to Avoid

Chris Olave vs. Patriots

To be clear, “Avoid” means “find a player with similar upside or lower expectations.” Because, let’s be real, few available WRs carry the same role as Chris Olave. 

• Targets per game: 10.2, 2nd (amongst all WRs – min. 100 routes)
• Targets per Route Run: 27%, T-6th 
• Catchable Targets per Game: 6.8, 6th 

However, he has an uphill battle against the Patriots. On paper, they look like an ideal unit. They’re 13th in PPR PPG allowed to receivers. However, the first two games of the season are inflating that average. New England gave up over 200 yards to the Raiders’ and Dolphins’ WRs across two straight games. Since then, they haven’t allowed more than 130. Even worse for Olave, their slot coverage has surrendered just 33.4 YPG to interior pass catchers. The Saints’ WR1 can use his floor of targets to squeeze out a viable performance, but it’s hard to project a high-end outcome against this coverage.

Join Our Newsletter

Trusted by 400,000+ fantasy football players. Get access to Fantasy Life's free award winning newsletter and tools, all in one step.

Email Address

Subscribe

By registering or logging in, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.